Contact Mutual of Indiana

Mutual of Indiana Insurance Company
415 Columbia Street,
Suite 3400
Lafayette, IN. 47901

Get directions to our office.

Telephone
1-800-782-6322

Office Hours
8:00am–4:00pm. (Eastern time)

Susan Taggart, CEO, PFMM, FMDC
Email: susan@mutualofindiana.com

Submit claims: claims@mutualofindiana.com
After Hours to report a claim: 317-491-3586

Please use the following form to contact us.

 
Reinsured by: